WITCH OF ENDOR AND SAMUEL'S "RESURRECTION"
King Saul needed a message from God. God would not speak. Samuel the prophet who could give a message was dead. So Saul disguises himself and finds a woman in Endor who reportedly could commune with the dead. She is known to posterity as the Witch of Endor.
She succeeded, or she seemed to!, in calling Samuel up and he
gave a message and complained about being disturbed. Christians say,
"The Bible does not say that the Witch of Endor called up Samuel
from the dead to speak with Saul. It says she tried to call him up
and he appeared which could mean that she had no power to do it but
it was God who made Samuel appear to her. She was shocked when she
saw the apparition probably meaning that she was not used to this
happening and it had been the first time."
The story says that the Witch called up Samuel and he appeared. It
does not tell us whether her call caused this or if God just let him
appear meaning it had nothing to do with her. In fact, reason says
she probably did. That is the way the story reads. Correlation is
not causation but nothing in the story fits the notion that she was
a complete fraud or even a fraud at all. Given that the Bible says
God is not an author of confusion and is a master teacher, we should
dismiss the notion that God by coincidence made Samuel appear when
she asked and it was not down to her.
Why did God or the Witch need Samuel to suffer the inconvenience of actually rising from the dead? Why can't like a medium could she not make do with a dream or some other way to get a message from the prophet?
Though the Bible condemns spirit mediums it never up to that point says that they cannot bring back the dead. It is only later on the notion that the dead cannot return surfaces. Luke 16 has Jesus declare that no power at all can make the dead come back. Only God can do that. If the New Testament is heresy and should not be added on to the Old Testament then there is no case theologically or scripturally to be made for saying that spiritism never has successful seances.
The medium was shocked but the story does not say why she was
shocked! If it was clearer or better than the usual apparitions it
could still shock her. Or it could be that she thought she had the
power to raise the dead but not a prophet of God!
Samuel complains about being disturbed as if he was forced to
appear. This matches the witchery claim that they can make the dead
manifest. Also, it is like Samuel died and knew it was happening and
is now baffled as to what he is doing back on earth and finds it a
nuisance. It is like he thinks he is resurrected. The story could be
Samuel be temporarily resurrected.
Samuel was there against his will for he would not appear for a
woman who was practicing forbidden arts which God proscribed on pain
of death. Samuel would not want to appear to help Saul either for
Saul was in the bad books with the prophet and with God. Even though
Samuel was giving a shocking message, it was still giving in to Saul
for Saul wanted a message bad or good.
The account indicates that it was the real Samuel for he is
presented as speaking as a prophet of God who could forecast the
future. It says his word was reliable. We have no reason to assume
it was not the authentic Samuel. We must interpret it no other way.
There is no room for speculation that it is another spirit
pretending to be him.
Samuel did not need to appear at all. A message would have done. That he appeared just as he was aged and before his death indicates just how much power was being attributed to this woman.
Samuel warns Saul of God's retributive wrath. Christians say the fact that Saul went to a medium was one of the reasons for God's ill-will. That is not in the text either.
The prophecy according to the story came true!!
The woman realises that her client is Saul.
Sirach, which is in the Catholic list of divinely inspired New
Testament books, says that before Samuel died, he promised God and
the king that he had been an honest man and never had stolen. Then
we read that even after he died he was able to really appear to Saul
and tell Saul what fatal end to expect. The text says that out of
the grave Samuel spoke as a prophet of God to call on the people to
desist from wickedness.
This story causes grave trouble for Christians. What if like Samuel,
Jesus was not raised from the dead but was forced to manifest and
imagined he had risen from the dead when he had not? What if a
powerful magician was the real power behind it? There is no evidence
or proof that the interpretation Christians impose on the story is
valid. That is why we cannot use the resurrection accounts as
instigators of faith for Jesus and the accounts accept the full
unconditional validity of the Old Testament.
You can suggest that Samuel chose to pretend to be Jesus and that
explains the visions after Jesus died.
One thing from the story is that Samuel was not happy at being not
left to rest. Many conclude that praying to and talking to your dead
loved ones is selfish. The story is that even if you can call up the
dead it is not right. Catholic saints are prayed to long before
canonisation is even considered. That says something about that
religion.