ROMAN CATHOLICISM IS ROMAN CATHOLICISM BUT NOT CATHOLICISM!
When the Christian faith left Judaism the narrative is that it was thrown out. The New Testament does say there were fights and disputes but it also says the Jews to an extent sought dialogue. It does not mention an excommunication.
In Acts 15 the apostles clearly without any authority from Judaism or Jewish organised religion start legislating and altering Jewish practice.
This is schism. The break with Judaism is too stark and too nasty. The end result cannot claim to be a Church that is about unity and peace. And yet that is what it boasts it is by calling itself Catholic.
Catholicity is held by Catholics to be a mark that designates them as the true
Church of God. The word Catholic means universal. To grasp what the word
Catholic means we should do what Father Richard P McBrien recommended on page 3
of his tome, Catholicism. We should look for the word that is opposite to
Catholic and that word is sectarian. The Catholic Church can be considered
sectarian in doctrine and in practice. And especially in the darker implications
of its teaching that it prefers to say little about. For example, most Catholics
believe women should be ordained as priests. These Catholics should be excluded
from the Church for wanting to be more inclusive to women. Why? Because, and
only if, the Church is right to say that if women are ordained their ordination
won't be valid and the power to give the sacraments will be lost so desiring
women priests is to desire to destroy the Church.
Catholic means not that all are in the Church but that the Church belongs to
all, that all ought to join it. Outsiders must abandon their former faith and
turn to the Catholic Church and believe what it says.
The Catholic Church proclaims that it is the true Church for it is in every
nation on earth and is meant to be joined by every nation and race. Jesus told
his people to preach to all creatures.
But if it were really Catholic then how could it be for people who do not even
realise that it exists? God must not want them to join. He has had plenty of
time to make the whole world know and understand Roman Catholicism.
This is just typical of the Catholic tendency to live in fantasy.
Roman Catholics are really Roman “Catholics”.
Universality alone proves nothing. Hundreds of religions claim to be for all
nations and people. Being the largest Church in the world would seem to make the
claims of Catholicism worthy of consideration for it seems to make it more
Catholic than other religions. But any one of the world’s religions could end up
huge some day. The Catholic Church was once a handful of people.
What was the Church in the days not long ago when it said that sincerity could
not save and that heretics and schismatics would all be damned? Later it began
to say that sincere Christians who were not Roman Catholics could be saved in so
far as they were sincere and holy. But the first teaching if incorrect would put
the Church outside the boundaries of Catholicity.
The Church says that being Catholic means that it is the true Church. So,
Catholic means being universally right and that it is the only ark of truth for
all.
Roman Catholicism is not Catholic because it is for those who are wrong and not
for those who are right. The idea of a wrong religion being Catholic is a
contradiction. Catholicism claims that Protestants are members of the Catholic
Church but who just don’t know it. That proves that it is not Catholic. For a
religion to be Catholic it has to claim that outside of it there is no salvation
at all. Your religious association and membership is caused by your faith –
faith is religion meaning that absolute doctrinal accuracy is required. A single
error or doubt means you are your own religion.
Catholicism is not a religion for it isn’t really one in faith which is enough
to expose the fact that it doesn’t bear the mark of Catholicity and has no right
to the name Catholic. And Jesus did say that only a few would have the true
doctrine in its purity and apostasy was predicted for most Christians. The
errors of the Church are so serious that high-level Catholics could not possibly
have a sincere faith.
The Church of Rome is not Catholic for it and its God excommunicate people
unjustly. It is not for all people when it does that. If you sincerely believe
that the Church is wrong like all heretics do then you have done nothing to
deserve expulsion and being barred from her sacraments which express unity with
the Church. People who deny the shamelessly absurd dogma that doubt is a sin
have to go, for example. She exclaims that she cannot have them in her fold
until they retract and mean it.
Even if the excommunication is invalid the fact remains that a division has
occurred and is being upheld.
The Church of Rome is not Catholic for though she will baptise babies that will
not be raised as Catholics she bars Protestants from that other lesser sacrament
of unity, Holy Communion.
The Church has always denied that women can be validly ordained which means that
though they are equals to men they must not be treated as such. No matter how
great the need the Church will not ordain women proving that the stuff about
women having different roles to men is sexist prejudice for roles have to be
dispensed with when the need is great enough. A religion that abuses is not
Catholic. It does not really want the persons it is hostile towards. They don’t
get a proper welcome.
The Church of Rome’s Catholicity would be more important than her money, altars
or Church buildings or anything else. She has to continue it to be the true
Church. Yet she raises mountains of money while the poor die of hunger and the
lack of medical attention. She is not here for those people so she is not
Catholic. How could she be for all people when her actions kill them before they
have a chance to even hear about the Church? If we believe in Jesus’ Sermon on
the Mount which hates people displaying their virtue we can be sure that
claiming to be Catholic is unchristian.
For anybody to call themselves Catholic is to boast that they know it all.