Is God a human instinct?
The atheist author Jesse Bering says yes. His book, The God Instinct, is a good
study of the question.
He thinks the instinct or illusion of God is down to evolutionary and social
causes. It is used by nature to stop us tearing each other apart so that we can
evolve and form communities. It is programmed into us for it is useful in terms
of evolution. Bering argues that God is more than just wish-fulfilment.
The main trigger for the programming was the destructive power of gossip. People
began to believe in prosocial gods or a prosocial God. Prosocial divinities
serve the purpose of enforcing our social rules by threatening punishment on
gossips and other destructive people. Clearly religion and God and prayer
condition the victim to become a danger to people perceived as a threat to the
community. Instead of following God to celebrate the goodness of human nature,
the believer uses God to manipulate the community and tacitly threaten it.
Evidence for the instinct is how even unbelievers tend to treat corpses as
somehow alive or think of them as hearing them. We are programmed to impose a
cognitive illusion on ourselves though we know the dead are dead and that is
that.
Other evidence is that we think our minds are not material things but like
spirits. The first and main thing you will ever experience is your own mind. You
cannot measure it or weigh it so it is like a ghost living in your skin. This
causes the intuition that there are other immaterial or spiritual minds. But
this intuition is caused by an error. If a primitive brain was made in a lab and
had an eye it would think there was nothing to it but sight. It would experience
existence as if there was sight but no eyes. It would feel like a ghost just
because it cannot know or sense that it is a material being.
Further evidence comes from the 2003 cross-cultural study referred to by Bering
that shows bigger communities are more likely to accept and promote moralising
Gods - whether they are polytheistic or monotheistic. Weaker communities or
individualistic societies tend to have gods who are not very worried about right
and wrong. Read page 193.