Religion is cognitive dissonance at work
Cognitive dissonance is when you are attached to beliefs or values so that
you start lying to yourself and going into denial when you encounter evidence
that your attachment is gravely misplaced. It is a way of protecting yourself
from the pain of discarding the beliefs or being shown wrong. It only happens if
the beliefs somehow trap you.
Religion is the main manifestation of cognitive dissonance so religion then
is founded on a tendency to hurt yourself if your faith or religious identity
gets a challenge - especially a good one! You violate your right to peace by
stressing yourself and blaming the evidence. You hurt yourself as a weapon to
silence the critic and the evidence. Violence breeds violence. It helps explain
why religion is so potent when it comes to generating hate and division and
violence. Dissonance leads to dissonance so the religious end up in denial about
how dangerous their faith and they are.
Religion and belief in the supernatural are the worst for creating cognitive
dissonance and to see that all you need to do is look. Thinking God is guiding
or inspiring you is the biggest and fastest short-cut to cognitive dissonance.
Why? Because it is easier to believe a lie if you think you are wrong to see it
as a lie. You can tell yourself that God is revealing it to you as true and that
overrides evidence that it in fact is false. You see it as a case where what is
true seems to be a lie. Also, there is God and Satan to influence you so if you
find disproof of God's existence it may be fake and down to Satan tampering with
evidence. Also, there is how God can suspend natural law and maybe does
undetectable miracles such as working in your heart. Maybe he does miracles only
you can be aware of for they are internal. All these things have no reality
check.
Religious cognitive dissonance will create more fear and hatred of anything that
may challenge the dissonance than any other form for it is strongest and hardest
to cure and also because it turns your interpretation of God and religious stuff
into practically God. Your ideas of God become God to you and thus you must be
better than God when you can create this God! Dissonance that deals with things
you consider of absolute and infinite and ultimate purpose and value naturally
has to be the most intransigent and the biggest dissonance time bomb.
Festinger in the book Doubting Jesus' Resurrection: Suppose an individual
believes something with his whole heart; suppose further that he has a
commitment to this belief, that he has taken irrevocable actions because of it;
finally, suppose that he is presented with evidence, unequivocal and undeniable
evidence, that his belief is wrong: what will happen? The individual will
frequently emerge, not only unshaken, but even more convinced of the truth of
his beliefs than ever before....The dissonance [conflict between belief and
reality] would be largely eliminated if they discarded the belief that had been
disconfirmed....Indeed this pattern sometimes occurs....But frequently the
behavioral commitment to the belief system is so strong that almost any other
course of action is preferable....Believers may try to find reasonable
explanations and very often they find ingenious ones....For rationalization to
be fully effective, support from others is needed to make the explanation or the
revision seem correct. Fortunately, the disappointed believer can usually turn
to others in the same movement, who have the same dissonance and the same
pressures to reduce it. Support for the new explanation is, hence, forthcoming.
From Doubting Jesus' Resurrection by Kris Komarnitsky.
With religions of love, the believers go to worship and hail vindictive
scriptures and Messiahs and Gods. This has to be some kind of Attention Deficit
Disorder - a self-inflicted one! It is certain that the most devoted believers
do have some kind of disorder.
People engage in cognitive dissonance as a placebo. What makes the problem worse
is being part of a group that practices the dissonance and this gives it the
appearance of validity. If you are part of a superstitious crazy group, you will
soon start to think like the people in it. It is harder to doubt that the cow
down the road is the creator of the universe if your neighbours think it is and
keep showing their devotion. Needing to be part of the group is enough to
pressure you and start you off exercising cognitive dissonance. That is why if
religion is wrong or man-made we need to find the exit door and use it.
One problem with cognitive dissonance is that if you know it is present, you
cannot know exactly what the disconnect from reality is. For example, if a
religion claims that all women are really aliens and not human at all it would
seem that those who support the doctrine are disconnected from the truth about
women. But what if the dissonance is not that at all. Maybe through cognitive
dissonance they think they believe what they do not believe at all for it is too
silly?
Most people these days in a religion will disagree with many of its main and
required teachings. Though they are not philosophers or theologians they will
consider those doctrines to be irrational and silly. They are virtually telling
us that the dogs in the street know that the philosophical and theological
giants and academics are wrong. It seems arrogant for the layperson to
contradict the experts. But is it? Are they not suggesting that those people
want to be fooled and fool others with nonsense? They are admitting the power of
cognitive dissonance and yet they are staying in a religion and passing it on to
their kids that they believe is just the creation of dissonance.
Some cherry-pickers of a religion are engaging in cognitive dissonance which
takes the form of the critics greatly esteeming the philosophers and theologians
of their religion while trying to turn off the part of their brain that calls
them charlatans and liars.
Cognitive dissonance reminds us that if you call a religious person sincere
though he spouts absurdities beyond belief that you could mean the part of them
that believes the nonsense is sincere and the other part of them that knows it
is drivel is insincere.
A religion of self-deception is more dangerous and worse than a religion that is
a con. It is the worst nightmare - collective cognitive dissonance! It is child
abuse to make a child religious or to try to.