HOW TO CREATE ORDER
Creating order is the only way to do what people call morally good.
To do that we must have laws.
We forbid stealing. What is stolen has to be returned. Not paying a fair wage or
the best wage you can is theft.
We forbid slander. We forbid backbiting for we all have weaknesses and have done
terrible things or would have done them given the chance.
We forbid murder. We forbid people who are able from not coming to the aid of
others who are being attacked.
We forbid unfair discrimination based on sex, age, belief, nationality and
colour. Discrimination should be based on ability or the lack of it.
We forbid the concealment of crime for that is just rewarding the crime. Some
will claim that they committed a crime because they had had a hard time and were
angry at the world. Why believe them?
We forbid the pollution of the environment.
We forbid parents not supporting their children. We do not forbid partners
cheating on one another for they can be there for their children even if they do
break up. We forbid it for other reasons.
We forbid rape and sex involving people under sixteen. The young person who
resists the pressure to have sex is the strong one and the really normal one.
Normality is judged by referring to the use of commonsense to do the best thing
for yourself and others.
We only permit these things when lives are at stake or for the sake of a greater
good. For example, the dirt will have to be dished on a person when it is for
the equal or greater good of another.
Some may object: “Why these rules and not others? Order will still be maintained
if we permitted racism and a certain amount of murder. You can’t say that
permitting these is bad for it causes trouble for the law has to be enforced by
causing trouble.”
The answer is that these two things would be needless evils. The rules need to
be as liberal as possible for you don’t need a lot of control over people to
organise society. Where there is no law we have to live as if there were a law.
We have to live out the best code of right behaviour that we can find.
We feel that we want these rules. Even when we feel like breaking them we prefer
them to be maintained for they make us feel safe. The way we naturally feel
about them would be a sufficient reason to stand by them and preach them for
that would guarantee the greatest possible happiness of the greatest number in a
harmless way.
Thomas Hobbes insisted that human beings are fundamentally and essentially
selfish with each one caring only about his own needs and being willing to harm
others to fulfil them. He said that one proof of this was the way we locked our
doors at night when we retired. He said that though there are public officers
and laws to protect us we would attack any burglar (Leviathan, chapter 13). This
attitude of Hobbes drew him to the conclusion that everybody should be
controlled almost completely by the state and the law. He wanted the lions,
human variety, caged in by laws and restrictions. This he felt was the only way
to make human beings behave themselves. This was necessary because there are
ways a person can commit crimes and guarantee or almost guarantee getting away
with them. A person can tell a discreet lie about somebody to get the job the
other person is after, for example. So the law needs to be geared to prevent
this being possible. The answer is that true rational self-interest does not
need to want to hurt other people and so a big brother state is not needed.