PAUL'S HALLUCINATIONS OF THE "RISEN" JESUS?
The gospels say that a miracle healing man called Jesus Christ lived. They say
he died by crucifixion and three days later he rose again. The tomb he was
placed in was found wide open with the stone that had been across the entrance
moved back and the tomb was mysteriously empty. His body was gone. Certain
witnesses claimed that Jesus appeared to them as a resurrected being. Famously
Jesus appeared to anti-Christian Paul and turned him into the main apostle!
The resurrection of Jesus is one of Christianity's core doctrines. It is
essential. It is at the root of what Christianity is all about.
Christians claim psychiatry shows that the witnesses should not be suspected of
suffering hallucinations.
Paul is the only person who wrote down his claim that he saw the risen Jesus.
Paul in his writings showed signs of religious madness: "The appointed time has
been winding down and it has grown very short. From now on, let even those who
have wives be as if they had none. And those who weep and mourn as though they
were not weeping and mourning, and those who rejoice as though they were not
rejoicing, and those who buy as though they did not possess anything. And those
who deal with this world as though they were not absorbed by it and as if they
had no dealings with it. For the outward form of this world (the present world
order) is passing away" (1 Corinthians 7:29-32). The incoherence is plain. For
example, he asks those who should be mourning not to do it and then expects
others to mourn who should not be doing it. It is not like he considers mourning
or not mourning to be a block when you are preparing for the coming of Christ to
end the world. A man like that who predicts the end of the world as if it is
just days away and who asks for bizarre behaviour in preparation for it is
definitely mentally disturbed. His visions cannot be relied on or his reports of
them cannot be relied on. He would not be giving a command like that and would
not be able to get people to obey it unless he claimed he had been told all this
in a vision of Jesus! Even if he really did have visions, the visions lied and
so we are entitled to put them down as tricks of the psychic powers of the mind
or indeed from Satan if we wish. It would be blasphemous to take his visions
seriously for it would not be very dignifying for God if we did that.
Paul writes that fourteen years previous to writing he was taken up to the third
Heaven and he does not know if he was in his body or out of it and was told
things so great that he cannot tell them. What does this tell us about Paul? He
was prone to boast and was able to hallucinate in such a way that he could not
tell if he was physically in Heaven or not. He had physical illusions. He
admitted to boasting. It is one thing to boast and give details about the
wonderful things you have heard. It is another to boast that you have heard
wonderful things and not give any details. That is what Paul did! He really
embarrassed himself in front of a rebel section of the Church! So great was his
ego! He boasted about this vision more than the one where he supposedly saw
Jesus! He told us more about it which makes us wonder how reliable he was when
he saw Jesus.
A mad apostle is looked up to by an eccentric Church. The Church should not be
taken seriously.