CHRISTIAN CLAIM THAT EVIL IS A LACK NOT A CREATED THING IN THE LIGHT OF DIRECT EVIL-DOING
The Christian belief that good is real and evil is a bad attempt at good is
interesting. It is at the root of the belief that there is no war or fight
between evil and good because good was there first and is the default. Evil is
the attacker punching above its weight and thus is nothing important.
It blames you if evil does not feel that way right now.
Human nature tries to find something it likes in everything in order to cope or
to quell the pain of compassionate feelings. To do this to honour God and
affirm that evil is an abuse of good and thus of him is totally unacceptable.
Totally.
You don't need to be a Christian or even a believer in God to think that evil is
just good that has lost its way. But such a belief can be very dangerous if you
are wrong. It borders on arguing that you need do nothing about evil for good
will handle it anyway. It borders on saying that maybe your efforts to deal with
evil are not what paid off after all. The evil was going to disintegrate
with our without your help.
In the past, people always thought that evil and suffering were directly
administered by God. Many people without relevant education in the developed
world today think the same thing.
Before it was known that bacteria were causing many human diseases, people
believed that God was causing the illness directly. He was putting the rot into
a limb scheduled for a cruel painful amputation. God was putting the gangrene
in. To believers, being upset about your sins and going to get forgiveness means
that evil of being upset is good in that case. So the evil of gangrene must be
good for some reason. To cut off the limb is to defy God. It is trying to
correct God. The notion does nothing to discourage the causing of suffering but
encourages letting it happen. If God makes only good and evil is merely good in
the wrong place, God is still good despite putting gangrene in a person. He is
still good for doing this for gangrene has a good side - for example it is being
a good disease by doing destruction. In that case then he might not mind us
doing nothing about suffering or even causing it. He can delegate the authority
to us to cause suffering on the basis that we are making only good and not
causing the failings in that goodness for the failings are not real things.
That people would adore a God who they see as doing direct evil is frankly
disturbing. Even if they don't do that any more, we are still left wondering
what kind of hearts people have when it comes to God.
God takes life. Is death then the mere absence of life?
Death is probably the best example we know of evil.
If evil is the absence of good and no more, then death is the absence of life
and no more. But death is a power that keeps the cells from living. When
electrical activity dies out in the body other forces with no visible kinetic
energy take over. These are the same forces that make a stone a non-living
entity.
If evil is misplaced good, then why isn't death misplaced life?
God has to replace the power of life with a power that makes the body lifeless.
Lifelessness is a power. A piece of metal is full of power when it is heated but
when it cools another power takes over, cold. You can't say that heat is the
mere absence of cold or that cold is the mere absence of heat for that makes no
sense. They are powers. To say that death is just the absence of life is
irreverent to the thing that matters most, life. If life is good then it follows
that God should have made everything alive for the absence of life is evil. The
defence fails totally to defend God’s reputation for he makes the forces and
uses the forces that are death and which cause death. It slanders him while
boasting that it salvages his good name. To claim that God doesn't kill is to
belittle those who die for they know he does.
The Bible is said to talk as if God did evil directly
when it in fact he is the first cause and it is secondary causes that do the
evil. So they deny that is direct. But the Bible DOES clearly and
repeatedly teach that God DOES EVIL DIRECTLY. He gave the commands to have
sinners killed and gave the commands directly. A sabbath breaker was
stoned to death at God's command. Jesus walked to his death deliberately
and thus harmed his killers if you believe the killer harms themselves as much
as the victim. That was a direct evil too.