How Atheists or Sceptics about religion have a sense of the value of life
"People say that we’re searching for the meaning of life. I don’t think that’s
it at all. I think that what we’re seeking is an experience of being alive, so
that our life experiences on the purely physical plane will have resonances
within our own innermost being and reality, so that we actually feel the rapture
of being alive." The Power of Myth by Joseph Campbell.
Comment: An occasional or rare joy at JUST being alive is
all that is really needed. A meaningless life is tolerable as long as you think
and know this experience can happen. Religion only adds to misery by offering
answers that are not answers. You don’t actually need answers. You need the
rapture. So it is possible to have a meaningless life and be compensated
by this flash of meaning. The psychological meaning of life matters not the
spiritual or any other kind.
_______________________________
You think life is worth living for you would not be here
if you did not.
If you say life is worthless you must consider it worth your while to say that
meaning you do consider your life to be worthwhile.
A sense of meaning is default and automatic and cannot be destroyed except by
extreme mental melancholy - you have to be mentally ill.
You must make the purposes of your life yourself and you do that by living in
the world and availing of its opportunities instead of trying to fool yourself
with magic and prayers and sacraments and religions. There is no one purpose. It
is cruel and manipulative and hypocritical and ignorant to say there is for we
all get through the day by having countless reasons for living. Those reasons
change from day to day. Our feelings change all the time.
Broadly there is the meaning as in why you would do good, why you would be happy
and why you would suffer? The question for why do good is considered the
paramount one. Indeed the others cannot matter if it does not matter. Do good is
broad as well - it refers to what you do for yourself such as getting a good
hair cut, eating responsibly as well as what you do for others. God and the
meaning of life are too often linked together. Let us deal with that problem
first and then explore how a sense of meaning helps with goodness, happiness and
suffering.
Nihilism says you must make no definitive commitment to anything for it will not
last and all things are fleeting. But to not make a commitment is to commit
yourself to not making one!
The objections to getting meaning without God
People tell you you need to love God to have meaning in life.
A stunning landscape with rolling hills and stately trees
has no meaning until you give it meaning. When you go and walk through it and
enjoy it it gets meaning then. Believers say that. They say that we have no
meaning either unless God exists and gives it to us by putting us into his
lovely plan. They think you are valueless if there is no God. But if you
are valueless without God then if there is a God, he treats you as valuable.
But if you are not valuable nothing can make you valuable. God does not
really make you valuable. It is patronising and insulting. Better to make life
meaningful without God if you have to do that! It will not lead to virtue but to
passive aggressive faith. Do we see the hidden ingredient in faith that causes
it to turn violent and enabling of violence so easily?
Incredibly Christians will tell a person how that person hardly registers in
importance when you consider how big the universe is, how many people there are,
and how long the universe has been around. They argue then that it is arrogant
to say you can make meaning for your own life and do not need God to give it to
you - a God who puts you in a vast universe and adores you with all his heart
despite the unimportant status the universe gives you. But if there is no God or
insufficient evidence there is nothing arrogant about trying to give your life
meaning. It is not your fault that you are so small and being small does not
make you insignificant. A tiny diamond is worth more than a hundred tonne of
dirt. To tell you that you should not try to make the best if your life just
because you are a dot in a vast universe is just cruel. It is obvious that you
should still try. There is no alternative so in a sense there is no should about
it.
Religion says that if you are just a collection of atoms you have no meaning. So
they say you are more than that and there is a God and so life has meaning. You
are intrinsically valuable. But you could still be a mere machine though you do
not feel you are if there is a God. And what if God has some unexplainable way
of giving you meaning if you are just a bag of atoms and bits and bobs?
Nobody can prove that faith in God or religion gives them meaning. Anybody who
finds a way to feel reasonably in control of life will get a sense of meaning
for we fear the mechanical and the random and the uncertain. Meaning does not
come from the sense of control that religious faith gives. It comes from the
sense of control that faith gives. Faith is more important and basic than
religious faith. If you make a mistake with this control aspect and start
depending on God that could be dangerous for it is looking for control in a
disordered and unnecessary way.
Religion says that God and morality cannot be separated. Morality supposedly
stands ultimately only on God. Religion then argues that morality is about what
is supposed to be and the kind of person you must become meaning that morality
implies there is a purpose for your life. This is the kind of logic that goes,
"You can't call sunlight good. It is merely functional. It does a job." You
cannot call your shoes good for they function as protection for your feet. But
that is obviously deranged logic. Functional IS GOOD!
If you say justice and love are nonsense you redefine
justice and love for you say that it is unfair to say justice is real and you
say it is unloving to tell the lie that love exists. These things have
nothing to do with God. You cannot get away from the ideas of fairness and
love. Thus you do not need God for morality and it is actually immoral to
think you do. Fix your perception of justice and love instead of looking
for God to ground a morality that is already grounded.
Religious emphasis on meaning and getting it from God is about honouring God not
you. It is sought to please God and nobody else. That is the intention. If
meaning made your life a misery and that others just as bad it would still be a
duty if God comes first. People seeking happiness through meaning is ridiculous.
Why do good?
We should not need God or arguments to persuade us that good is good. We should
simply see it. The truly good person sees good as good for its own sake. If we
cannot manage that we will not be able to see our lives have meaning. We may
need religion as a prop to delude ourselves but it is still a dangerous
delusion. It is not the answer.
There is everything to be said for the fact that in relation to the meaning of
life, you either see it is worthwhile for its own sake or you don't. Trying to
find meaning shows that you are trying to find it artificially. It is like
seeing beautiful flowers and searching for reasons to find them beautiful
instead of just seeing them as beautiful. That would be forced and showing you
are really trying to see what you cannot see. You end up pretending you see it
or deluding yourself that you do.
If you enjoy the flowers, you simply enjoy them and do not have to check that
you enjoy them. Checking will actually only spoil your enjoyment. It distracts
from it. In reality you should be engrossed in the beauty. A sense of meaning
and worth in life just happens. It is vile of religion to say you need God and
religion to develop it.
The sense that your life is worth it will come from helping others. The best way
to remain motivated and willing to help others even to the extent of greatly
risking your health and life is to try and see the big picture. Try and see how
many can benefit from and be inspired by your actions. If you see yourself as
helping only a few, your motivation will not be very strong. Do not see just how
many will be directly helped but think of the indirect benefits too. Perhaps the
leper you treat will be able to find a wife and raise a nice family. Think also
of the opportunities you are making - you give those opportunities to others
even if they do not available of them. What matters is that you gave.
The notion that goodness has no real value without God or if we just all cease
to exist one day is a bizarre one. And arrogant. Those who use this argument say
that it has no ultimate value unless we live forever and there is a God.
The good you do has happened and cannot be made to not-have-happened. So its
value has nothing to do with what you think of it afterwards or if anybody
remembers it. Even if the universe dies one day, it will still have happened and
still have been beautiful.
If giving what little bread you have to a hungry child is unimportant unless
there is a God to approve of it and to remember it forever,
In summary, the good we do in this life has ultimate value without any recourse
to God or everlasting life or religion. In fact they only get in the way of it -
to what extent depends on the person. Good is independent of God and therefore
independent of faith in God and so it follows that God then is not the same
thing as goodness. So God is not God. An atheist can feel her life has meaning
far more than a Christian can. Sadly, atheism has not grasped this properly yet.
Finally
What about the thought that if life and the universe make no sense then they
ought to make sense? Camus asked that question. He made sense for it is
obvious that if you have to choose, "Nothing makes sense but it ought to", or,
"Nothing makes sense and it ought not to" then you have to choose the first.
Why? Because you still have two oughts so the first one is the wisest
choice. An ought not is still an ought. Meaning is a default and you
need to let it be a default. Meaning as in default is good and all you
need but meaning as in God is trying to get away from that so it is bad.
If a plan for your life is so fundamental then it is the
plan that matters not who makes the plan. Religion says that God and religion
gives your life meaning by making you part of a plan. They are hijackers. It is
not their's to give.
Good is real. Even if there were nothing at all there would still be some good.
Good is abstract but true but needs no maker. God only gets in the way so he is
not the source of meaning in life. The meaning of life is an illusion - it is
very complicated so you must be aware that life has meanings not meaning. If you
have such a terrible day that you feel like ending your life, remember how
everything changes and how complex it all is. The meanings of life then can work
their magic on you tomorrow. You can plant the seeds of hope instead of
magically thinking that belief in God is going to solve all your meaning issues.
A doctor who gives you aspirin for cancer is not helping you. You need complex
treatment that is subject to careful and responsible and constant revision.