A GOD WHO LETS EVIL HAPPEN IS THEREBY DOING EVIL
The notion that an all-good God lets evil and undeserved suffering happen
opposes the atheist view that evil and suffering are completely incompatible
with a loving God.
The atheist needs to tackle the issue from the viewpoint of compassion. The
atheist is willing to forgo his own peace of heart in order to detest the evil
that happens to others to the point that he refuses to say that it should happen
under any circumstances. The atheist should feel the pain and vow to be God to
those people and help them. Keep the focus on compassion and you will be
respected and the religious will not be able to speak.
That evil happens is the problem. Religion then tries to distract you from that
by saying, "God did not create evil for he is totally good" and "God puts up
with evil." The point is not what makes evil but that evil is there. It is not
very compassionate of religion to resort to such tactics.
Your baby suffers. Instead of accepting this, be defiant. Be willing to battle
even God to help the baby. Is prayer to God accepting the situation because you
cannot do anything else after you have done all you can think of? No. It is
letting God hurt the child for an alleged purpose. It is saying you agree with
him. If you accept you accept and prayer has nothing to do with it.
Some say that God respects our free will and indeed has to so he can let us do
gratuitous evil or useless evil. Not only that, he can let us break the record
in being evil. Letting us be free is one thing but going that far is too much.
Think carefully about the argument. If my free will is worth letting me create a
plague to torment and kill billions of people then that is saying I am so
important that it is worth it. Also, if free will is that precious it follows
that there is no such thing as gratuitous or extreme evil. But any person who
feelings of compassion knows there is!
Beliefs are forced on us by our environment and what we learn. If that does not
take away or lessen our free will then God should implant edifying and
life-transforming beliefs in us or do a better job of making sure man promotes
them. If has not done that so he has no excuse for letting us sin.
People are manipulated by religious leaders to think that God never does evil.
People take comfort from that and imagine that God is with them in their
suffering which he detests. He is always there to help.
They boast that this doctrine teaches you that suffering helps work out God's
lovely plan and so if you do not welcome suffering you must accept it and try to
see its value.
A God that permits evil to happen but doesn’t do evil is actually still doing
evil. Permitting evil is just another way of doing it.
God is worse than a God that actually does the evil he supposedly permits.
Permitting implies that God gives the evil free rein at least up to a point.
That means he abandons those who suffer. Jesus was right then to yell that God
abandoned him when he was on the cross. A God who does the evil to you is at
least in control all the way. It is more malevolent to let a machine
uncontrollably torment your child than to torment the child yourself.
Virtues such as diligence only makes sense if there is evil that is avoidable
and that should not exist or be allowed to exist. Atheism is the true friend of
goodness when correctly understood, not religion.
It is always wrong to condone God letting people suffer when there is no proof
that he cares and is right to let this happen. You need proof because it is such
a serious matter. You don't want to trivialise suffering to any level.
If I say I believe in an all-good God and then say I also believe there is no
justification for his letting people get depression then I am lying. I only
imagine I believe in God. One “belief” cancels the other out.
And I am complicit in God's evil for I desensitise myself to it and praise it
and hope that others copy me and do the same.