CATHOLICISM AND BIRTH-CONTROL
Contraception is using pills and devices to prevent conception. The Roman Catholic cult regards it as seriously sinful. The logic is that using birth control is about separating the means of getting a child from getting the child. It is about the pleasure not the child. This is regarded as lacking in virtue and failing to see the child as a gift in herself or himself and as a gift from God. Archbishop Fulton Sheen said it is like trying to have a world where your trees always bloom for your pleasure but never produce fruit and you are happy with that for you don't really value or think you need the fruit.
The Church has done its best to stop the use of condoms in Africa even
though this has resulted in millions dying of AIDS. It is clear that the Church
has no right to be so dogmatic on such an issue for dogma can stifle the truth.
The Church does not want to see if condoms will help which is clear from the
fact that a man having once-off sex is expected to do it without a condom and
put himself and his partner at risk. It does not care! Some Catholics teach
their ban doesn’t do any harm but still the fact remains that even if it does
they still believe the ban should be.
Even if birth control were a sin, there is no justification or reason in the
insistence of the Church that it is as bad as murder and you will go to Hell
forever if you die unrepentant of the sin of birth control just like you would
for murder. The stance of the Church is extremism and bigotry. The Church could
teach that it is venial sin - this is sin that you have to pay for by suffering
in Purgatory not a sin so serious that you would suffer punishment for it that
never ends and which can never end.
The Church says that sex must be open to life at all times and yet it allows you
to marry somebody you know is barren. The hypocrisy is astounding. It says you
must let God plan your family. This makes sense if there is a God which shows
how dangerous the concept of God is but it means you are not to blame if
pregnancy results and great misery happens because of it for it was God’s
decision to send the baby. This means if it is up to God it doesn’t matter if
you use the safe period in which conception is less likely or not. The Church
says fertility is a blessing and is natural and not a disease so contraception
is wrong and yet it allows you to wear contact lenses instead of getting laser
surgery on your eyes even though the laser would be less unnatural. It even lets
you have a nose job though there is nothing wrong with irregular features!
Pius XI made in infallible statement in part 54,56 condemning birth control in
his encyclical Casti Connubi: “No reason, however grave, may be put forward by
which anything intrinsically against nature may be conformable to nature and
morally good. Since, therefore, the conjugal act is destined primarily by nature
for the begetting of children, those who in exercising it deliberately frustrate
its natural power and purpose sin against nature and commit a deed which is
shameful and intrinsically vicious. Since, therefore, openly departing from the
uninterrupted Christian tradition, some recently have judged it possible
solemnly to declare another doctrine regarding this question, the Catholic
Church, to whom God has entrusted the integrity and purity of morals, standing
erect in the midst of the moral ruin which surrounds her, in order that she may
preserve the chastity of the nuptial union from being defiled by this foul
stain, raises her voice in token of her divine ambassadorship and through Our
mouth proclaims anew, any use whatsoever of matrimony used in such a way that
the act is deliberately frustrated in its natural power to generate life is an
offence against the law of God and of nature, and those who indulge in such are
branded with the guilt of grave sin”.
Catholic teaching is that uninterrupted tradition is infallible and any change
is heresy. The pope says that he is speaking with the Church and nobody can
contradict him so he is speaking infallibly. He says God has guided him and the
Church to this decision.
It is one of the heresies of the modern Church that natural family planning is
fine for any reason but the actual teaching of the Church is that it is only
allowed in grave and extreme cases! The permitting of the natural method of the
Catholic Church was introduced by Pius XII. Tradition was wholly against him.
This modification of the teaching was heresy too.
The natural method was only permitted because the encyclical of the previous
pope, Pius XI, Casti Connubi was misunderstood. That pope permitted sex if the
couple was sterile or too old to reproduce. This permission was misinterpreted
without warrant to refer to the natural method in its Rhythm Method form or the
use of the safe period. The pope is thought to have written the following about
those married couples who had sex during the infertile time of the month. His
encyclical says: “Nor are these considered as acting against nature who in the
married state use their right in the proper manner, although on account of
natural reasons either of time or certain defects, new life cannot be brought
forth” Pope Pius XI. Time had to mean old age. Certain defects refers to
sterility. It is stretching the meaning to think he meant the safe period with
the intent to avoid children. It contradicts what he said that nothing
whatsoever must be done to prevent conception. He did not mean the safe period
because it is not fully safe. He speaks of a condition in which new life cannot
be brought forth so he is not thinking of it at all.
He says nothing of having sex while knowing a baby cannot come. Back then there
was no real way to be very sure. All he is saying is that if a couple have sex
when it may be the infertile time, they do not sin. The reason they do not sin
is because they don’t know the chances of conception and don't intend to avoid
conception. They are not sinning as long as they don't mean to prevent
conception. The pope gave no impunity from sin to those who had sex while
believing a baby couldn’t result. If you have sex with your wife and don’t know
her chances of conceiving when it may be her infertile time there is no sin.
That is all he is saying.
Pius XI had no problem with Catholics having sex during the safe period. He just
had a problem with them using this period as a form of birth control. He never
mentions in the encyclical that that is allowed. The natural method was well
known in his day. For him, the birth control he meant included natural and
artificial methods.
In 1951, Pope Pius XII, 29th October, said that natural family planning was
allowed only when a doctor had decided the wife should have no more babies for
it would destroy her health or when the family is afflicted by severe poverty.
So the circumstances are very abnormal.
Natural family planning can lead to the same contraceptive mentality that the
Church condemns contraception for: the feeling that a baby is a burden and not a
gift from God and its conception is to be avoided. With the doctrine that
natural family planning is forbidden except in extreme circumstances, at least,
you can hold that you really want a baby but can’t have one perhaps because
another pregnancy could kill the mother.
The Catholic Church and many other Churches claim to care about the family.
If so why do they have no problem providing marriage for immature people,
sixteen year olds, and people who may be unsuitable for raising children? They
are the people that claim that marriage is for procreation. Where are the
courses to prepare couples for children?
The Catholic Church condemns single mothers but nothing was said about Pope Pius
IX taking a Jewish boy from his parents and raising him himself. If single
parents are so bad then why is the surviving member of a married couple one of
whom died prematurely leaving children allowed and encouraged to keep the
children?
It is up to each individual couple to decide for themselves if contraception is
a bad thing or not in their marriage. The Church tells them to believe it is
bad. But belief colours your perception. No marriage is perfect. The Church is
encouraging couples to blame contraception for these normal imperfections and
problems. And they have to lay loads of blame on it for contraception is
supposed to be a very very serious sin. This is psychological manipulation.
If contraception causes problems in marriage, one answer would be for the
husband and wife to maybe have plenty of affectionate sessions with no sex or no
penetration, or to engage in masturbation sessions in which they watch one
another masturbate (the Church says masturbation is a sin) so that they use it
less.
But if a husband and wife are intimate friends and intimate parents and not just
intimate sexually the problems should not arise. If contraception causes
problems they must only be minor.
The Church wants the use of contraception to stop. It wants to stop a couple
having the option. If nobody uses condoms, they will disappear from our
pharmacies and those who seek them will not find them.
Research shows that young people who are below 17 and who have sex are less
likely to use contraception. Church teaching is a dangerous influence on them at
their impressionable age. Research shows that young people who are informed by
their parents about contraception are more likely to use it. The Church would
seek to block their right to know these things. It is so unfair because most
young people have sex from 17 to 19.
The Natural Family Planning Method is no use to many teenagers and young women
for their menstrual cycles are irregular. There is no way to tell for sure when
they are most likely to become pregnant. And teenage stress and exam angst,
heavy drinking, sickness, drugs, medication and travel can make periods so
irregular that there is no point in trying to figure out when the woman is in
danger of pregnancy.
THEOLOGY AND BIRTH CONTROL
Everybody knows what the Catholic Church thinks about the pill, condoms,
intrauterine devices and sterilisation. It says they are all seriously wrong and
never ever justified. The Church however allows NPF, natural family planning
based on the time during a woman's menstrual cycle when she is unlikely to
conceive. The Church says there is a huge moral difference between contraception
and natural family planning. It says contraception is suppressing fertility
while natural family planning is working with it.
Working with it? Working around it more like! It is still treating fertility as
something to be avoided. If that is okay, then contraception can't be wrong . If
sex must be open to life, then why not allow condoms for they don't always give
100% protection anyway? Even the Church says that contraception is not a sin if
it practiced by people who seriously think that it is acceptable before God.
This tells us that it cannot be a sin unless it means people knowingly and
evilly treat their fertility as a curse at least for a time. But using NPF
doesn't mean you don't have that kind of attitude. Many users will have the
attitude. It is the attitude that causes the moral problem for the Church. It is
lunacy to say that contraception is wrong for it must always express a bad
undesirable attitude.
The Catholic Church teaches that artificial birth control is always immoral even
when it is to prevent a husband infecting his wife with the AIDS virus. The idea
that contraception is bad has more to do with hatred of sexuality and the desire
to see it punished by having unwanted babies than with any real concern for the
people who use it or need it. Contraception must be the worst sin possible when
it is better if you are having sex to risk your life and bringing sick babies
into the world to suffer by neglecting contraception. Nothing is that bad that
it can be banned under all circumstances. The Church allows killing in
self-defence for heaven’s sake!